The National League rookie of the year race is the most stacked I can recall. Like, ever. Look at some of these young men:
Buster Posey: .331/.383/.502, 8 HR, 79 H, 265 PA
Jason Heyward: .262/.377/.451, 12 HR, 90 H, 413 PA
Gaby Sanchez: .290/.354/.455, 12 HR, 118 H, 457 PA
Mike Stanton: .260/.338/.531, 12 HR, 50 H, 220 PA
Tyler Colvin: .254/.313/.518, 18 HR, 71 H, 308 PA
Starlin Castro: .319/.365/.447, 3 HR, 343 PA
Jamie Garcia: 7.05 K/9, 2.71 ERA, 1.31 WHIP, and a 10-5 record.
John Axford: 10.7 K/9, 3.03 ERA, 1.24 WHIP, and 17 saves in 19 opportunities.
He’s just outside of this class at the moment, but in other years would be in the running: Ike Davis is posting a .251/.327/.433 line with 15 long balls in 407 PAs.
No other pitchers really factor in here: Strasburg’s thrown too few innings to be relevant (though his 10.6 K/9, 5.0 K/BB, and 0.80 WHIP make you catch your breath), and Mike Leake has come back to earth. I don’t think Garcia’s numbers are impressive enough to run with those position players. Posey looks like he’s somewhere between Jesus H. Christ and Joe Mauer, the sequel. He’ll put in enough plate appearances to be in the running, and you have to feel like he’s the best bet.
The AL doesn’t even come close to this young crop of talent. Austin Jackson is putting up a very solid campaign with a .305/.354/.406 line but only one long ball and 34 extra base hits. Brennan Boesch was out early and strong and has a .281/.344/.480 line on the year with 14 home runs, but in his last 36 games is only .203/.295/.289.
For the record: Mr. Mat Latos pitched for two outs too many in 2009 to be considered here, but, for the fun of it: 8.7 K/9, 1.0 WHIP, and a tidy little 12-5 record.